Jake Lynch (14): Dublin Coroner Decides On Open Verdict In Prozac Induced Suicide Case

For more about the inquest, please read Leonie Fennell’s beautifully written blog post-


“….The last word must go to Jake. It clarifies exactly what his family have been fighting for. In an e-mail the night before his death, he said (verbatim).. “The ‘anti-anxiety’ stuff is actually an anti depressant which they didn’t tell me. Probably doesn’t make much of a difference, but I feel like I’m drugged to the point that it suppresses everything bad until it suddenly spills out.”…

Note :15 minutes after posting this- the Irish Independent did an article on the coroners verdict. Personally I don’t think the article, or the quotes from either of the psychiatrists, Dr Brian Houlihan (the consultant for the court), or Dr Maria Migone (the psychiatrist who prescribed Jake Prozac), go anywhere near far enough in explaining the effects of these drugs.

Dr Houlihan’s quote saying that-

“.. Prozac can lead to increased suicidal ideation in some patients, but not to increased instances of suicide.”

           -is absurd. If Prozac leads to an increase in suicidal ideation in some patients, logic would follow that some patients will act upon them. To say in one breath that Prozac can cause suicidal thoughts (ideation) in some people but not actual suicide is so ridiculous it’s beyond words. Albeit perhaps the increase is small, but to say that the suicidal thoughts increase but that no suicides come from these suicidal thoughts in any patients ever- is really stretching logic if you ask me…

Dr Maria Migone’s lame attempt at insinuating autism is a more likely cause for Jake’s suicide also falls flat

“Consultant child psychiatrist Dr Maria Migone, who prescribed the Prozac for Jake’s anxiety, said new findings emerging in the past two years showed that children on the autistic spectrum were at increased risk of suicide.”

The only difference in Jake’s life was the Prozac, it doesn’t take Sherlock Holmes to see that Prozac is the factor which changed in Jake’s life… his parents, and Jake, were dealing very well with his Autism. Trust a psychiatrist to blame the patient, or the patient’s illness/diagnosis/condition. They’ve been getting away with this charade for far too long…

Coroner Dr Brian Farrell returned an open verdict concluding lengthy inquest proceedings dating back to May 2014.

Stephanie McGill Lynch shed tears and clutched her husband’s arm as the verdict was read out at Dublin Coroner’s Court.

“It’s a huge relief. It allows us to grieve now. You can’t let go of that night but this allows another chapter to close. This is the verdict he deserved because in our eyes it was drug induced,” she said after the inquest concluded.

Mrs McGill Lynch said she was unaware of the side effects of the drug.

Steph and John Lynch lost their son Jake to a Prozac induced suicide on March the 20th 2013. Today marks the culmination of a long battle for the Lynch’s to get a proper verdict from the coroners court in Dublin. I wasn’t at today’s hearing in Dublin’s coroner’s court, but I was at the last hearing, and I just want to say well done to Steph and John for persevering with dignity despite an arrogant and rude opposition from the challenging solicitors in this case. I hope that the Irish, and international press, report on this landmark ruling.

SSRI’s can cause suicide, and Prozac is no different to Seroxat/Paxil in that regard.

A recent re-interpretation of an older study (Study 329) showed that Seroxat is even more harmful than was first thought, and this re-interpretation has profound implications for all SSRI’s (Prozac included) and indeed medicine itself. (see here for details). Another recent study showed that SSRI’s are linked to increases of violence in young people (see here)

These drugs all work on similar neurotransmitters, they all cause akathisa and out of character behavior, and the side effects are the same across the board.

Why did Irish psychiatry, the HSE and the Department of Health not warn Steph and John about these side effects? Why are parents, friends, and family members, still left in the dark about the possible effects of these drugs? Why aren’t doctors warning properly?

In Ireland the anti-depressant market is worth 70million. Surely that money would be better spent on therapists, and facilities such as Pieta House?

It’s understandable why doctors want to prescribe drugs, they’re relatively cheap and easy, and they don’t take a lot of effort, or time, however that doesn’t justify the willful ignorance on behalf of GP’s. Irish psychiatry defends the drugs because the drugs validate their profession therefore any criticisms of the drugs, are taken by Irish psychiatry, as a criticism of the profession itself; these are psychiatric ‘guild’ interests which take precedence over patient safety. The pharmaceutical industry is also extremely powerful and influential in Ireland, and it seems that the concerns of these various vested interests are more important to the Irish state than a young boy’s life, or indeed that of anyone prescribed these drugs.

Jake’s ‘open verdict’ is a triumph for the memories of all SSRI induced suicides.


Irish parents on losing their son to suicide aged 14: ‘After turning the life support machine off I threw the bottle of Prozac against the wall’

Published 21/07/2015 | 13:39

Steffini McGill Lynch and John Lynch from Clondalkin who tragically lost their son Jake McGill Lynch to suicide when he was 14. Pic: Justin Farrelly. 3

Steffini McGill Lynch and John Lynch from Clondalkin who tragically lost their son Jake McGill Lynch to suicide when he was 14. Pic: Justin Farrelly.

Sometimes Steffini Lynch drives to her son’s secondary school in Clondalkin to collect him… but he never comes out through the gates.

Fourteen-year-old Jake McGill-Lynch took his own life on March 20, 2013 and his parents are a long way from accepting that their beloved child is gone.

It’s the hardest challenge a parent can face; it’s harder still when there is even a semblance of a chance that the death was preventable.

Jake started taking the antidepressant Prozac seven weeks before he died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound.

Most will conclude that this was the tragic culmination of a  long-standing illness, or a simple case of cause and  effect. However, Jake was never diagnosed with  depression.

More to the point, there is evidence to suggest that antidepressants increase the risk of suicide and suicidal ideation in children and adolescents.

A Confirmation photo taken of Jake McGill Lynch from Clondalkin who tragically committed suicide when he was 14. Pic: Justin Farrelly. 3

A Confirmation photo taken of Jake McGill Lynch from Clondalkin who tragically committed suicide when he was 14. Pic: Justin Farrelly.

Jake’s parents, Steffini and John, say that they weren’t told about the drug’s side-effects.

The Patient Information Leaflet for Prozac, which can be found on the HPRA (formerly the Irish Medicines Board) website, and which was in place at the time Jake took his own life, carries a warning that “Patients under 18 have an increased risk of side-effects such as suicide attempt, suicidal thoughts and hostility (predominantly aggression, oppositional behaviour and anger) when they take this class  of medicines.”

John and Steffini say they were never told this.

“They say it is not to be given to children under the age of 18 unless they have a diagnosis of moderate to severe depression,” says Steffini. “Jake had none of that. He had anxiety which is part and parcel of Asperger’s [Syndrome].”

Jake was diagnosed with Asperger’s Syndrome, which is an autism spectrum disorder, in 2012. He was intermittently seeing a psychologist at Clondalkin Linn Dara Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services.

Steffini, who is keen to convey that Jake didn’t have a critical need for talk therapy, says he met with the psychologist once a month. “However, before Christmas, he hadn’t seen her for four months.”

His anxiety increased ahead of his Junior Certificate and the psychologist referred Jake to a consultant psychiatrist in January 2013.

At the time, Steffini was still waiting for an occupational therapy appointment and had also asked the psychologist about CBT (cognitive behavioural therapy).

On January 31, 2013, John took Jake to the appointment with the psychiatrist at which Jake was prescribed Prozac. John signed a consent form. The psychiatrist had not met Jake before this consultation.

“We didn’t research Prozac. We should have,” says Steffini.

“When I went into the pharmacist with the script, I said, ‘I’m a bit embarrassed, I have what looks like an adult prescription here but it’s actually for Jake’,” she continues.

“‘Don’t worry about it’, she said, ‘loads of kids are on it.’”

Steffini says a Patient Information Leaflet was not included with the drugs when she collected the prescription from the pharmacy.

Jake began to behave out of character six days later. He walked out of an exam halfway through, an act of defiance which was otherwise unheard of for the straight-A student who had an IQ of 146.

That night he cried for three hours and said: “You don’t know what it’s like in my head” when his parents tried to console him.

Steffini considered taking him to Tallaght A&E before reasoning that he was under intense pressure with his upcoming mock exams.

Jake McGill Lynch from Clondalkin who tragically committed suicide when he was 14. Pic: Justin Farrelly. 3
Jake McGill Lynch from Clondalkin who tragically committed suicide when he was 14. Pic: Justin Farrelly.

“He was inconsolable,” recalls Steffini. “We stupidly didn’t associate that with the drug. That should have been our lightbulb moment.”

John and Steffini say that had they been aware of the contraindications of SSRI antidepressants for under-18s, they would have known that this behaviour was a cause for alarm.

The Patient Information Leaflet for Prozac on the HPRA website has strict guidelines in relation to Prozac and adolescents.

Parents are advised to contact their doctor if symptoms including irritability and extreme agitation; untypical wild behaviour; restlessness and poor concentration develop, or worsen, when patients under-18 are taking Prozac.

Children with Asperger’s are structure dependent. They like order and they tend to take their meals and partake in activities at the same time each day.

“Jake would came home from school and he would sit there and not move until his homework was done,” explains Steffini.

On March 20, 2013, Jake didn’t sit down to do his homework. “When John came home from work, I said: ‘I think he might have had a row with the girlfriend in America as he’s been back and forth to the laptop’.”

“He was agitated,” adds John, “and his face was flushed.”

Jake had joined a gun club with his mother a few months previously. He didn’t enjoy other sports, which is not uncommon for people with Asperger’s, however he showed an immediate enthusiasm and aptitude for shooting.

“He won a medal and I’ve never seen such a big smile on his face,” recalls John. “That’s all a parent wants — for their child to be happy.”

That night, Jake asked his mother if he could take the gun out of its secure storage so that he could practise holding it.

“I hated telling him no because he never asked for anything,” explains Steffini. “I never hesitated… but I did f**k up big time by not taking the box [of bullets] away. And I have to live with that.

Steffini McGill Lynch and John Lynch from Clondalkin who tragically lost their son Jake McGill Lynch to suicide when he was 14. Pic: Justin Farrelly. 3
Steffini McGill Lynch and John Lynch from Clondalkin who tragically lost their son Jake McGill Lynch to suicide when he was 14. Pic: Justin Farrelly.

“People say, ‘well you didn’t know’. Of course I didn’t know. But we’re dealing with a fact and the fact of the matter is that I screwed up.”

They didn’t hear the fatal gunshot. It was the sound of silence — when they called Jake for his supper — that told them something was wrong.

John, a paramedic, bolted up the stairs to Jake’s bedroom where he performed CPR straight away. Jake was taken to Tallaght Hospital. He took his last breath at 3.30am.

“When we came back after turning the life support machine off I got the bottle of Prozac and threw it against the wall,” remembers Steffini.

“It was the only thing that had changed in Jake’s life — and I knew there and then.”

The inquest, which started on May 31 last year, is ongoing.

John and Steffini don’t just want a verdict. They want answers. They want to know why antidepressants sold in Ireland don’t carry a black-box warning as they do in the US.

They want to know why their son was prescribed an antidepressant when he was not diagnosed with depression.

“When the illness takes up one sentence on the Patient Information Leaflet and the side effects are three pages, there’s a problem,” says Steffini.

She cites a watershed case in the US where a judge concluded that a 15-year-boy was under the influence of Prozac when he fatally stabbed his friend.

Cases such as this one are known as ‘iatrogenic’ — caused by medical treatment. The term was brought forward in the Dail last week by Pádraig Mac Lochlainn of Sinn Féin.

“I met with the McGill Lynch family for the first time last year,” explains Mac Lochlainn. “One of the areas we looked at was the Coroner’s Act which is over 50 years old and in serious need of a comprehensive overhaul.

“We want to put forward a symbolic amendment known as ‘Jakes’s Amendment’. The idea is that the coroner could consider the issue of iatrogenic suicide.

There is a large amount of worldwide evidence that this medication has the potential to cause suicide and suicidal ideation in young people and we feel that this should be something that the coroner can rule on.”

John and Steffini insist that they are not out for “material gain”, nor are they anti-medication.

“We’re not trying to frighten people,” says Steffini. “We believe that medication should be the last resort, not the first one.

“If your child is stressed about exams or breaking up from a relationship… that’s not depression. That’s life.”

“It may sound old-fashioned, but sometimes we’re happy, sometimes we’re sad,” adds John.

They want to raise awareness around the risks of antidepressants.

They believe that their son would have made a difference in the world and now, more than two year they are determined to make that difference on his behalf.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s